Gangmax Blog

自由之思想,独立之精神

What Is the Difference Between Dpkg Apt-get and Aptitude

| Comments

From here.

Question

When installing a software via dpkg -i packageA.deb, will the dependencies required by packageA be downloaded and installed automatically? How is this different from using apt-get or aptitude?

Answer

No, dpkg only installs a package, so doing dpkg -i packageName.deb will only install this Deb package, and will notify you of any dependencies that need to be installed, but it will not install them, and it will not configure the packageName.deb because well…the dependencies are not there.

apt-get is a Package Management System that handles the installation of Deb packages on Debian-based Linux distributions. A Package Management System is a set of tools that will help you install, remove, and change packages easily. So apt-get is like a clever dpkg.

I like to think of the timeline this way:

  1. They came up with a way to “store” the files of an application in a “package” so that it can be easily installed. So, the Deb package (.deb extension file) was born.

  2. A .deb file contains the files needed by an application to run, as well as (I like to call it) “meta-data” that holds other information, such as the names of the dependencies the application needs. If you want to see the contents of a .deb file, you can use the command dpkg -c packageName.deb, and if you want to see this “meta-data” information, use the command dpkg -I pacakgeName.deb (and if you want to only see the dependencies, do dpkg -I packageName.deb | grep Depends).

  3. They needed a tool to install these .deb files, so they came up with the dpkg tool. This tool, however, will just install the .deb file, but will not install its dependencies because it doesn’t have those files and it does not have access to “repositories” to go pull the dependencies from.

  4. Then, they came up with apt-get, which automates the problems in the previous point. Underneath the hood, apt-get is basically dpkg (so apt-get is a front-end for dpkg), but a clever one that will look for the dependencies and install them. It even looks at the currently installed dependencies and determines ones that are not being used by any other packages, and will inform you that you can remove them.

aptitude then came along, and it’s nothing but a front-end for apt-get [so, it’s a front-end of a front-end]. aptitude is a UI (user interface) for apt-get. If you want to see this UI, simply type aptitude in the terminal; that’s aptitude, that’s what it was originally created for. aptitude leverages the apt tools to provide more options and perks than apt-get. For example, aptitude will automatically remove eligible packages, while apt-get needs a separate command to do so. But, in the end, doing sudo aptitude install packageName.deb is the same as sudo apt-get install packageName.deb. There might be subtle differences here and there that I do not know about, but they will both look for the dependencies and do all that stuff. You can read the answer here for more information on the differences between aptitude and apt-get.

Also, aptitude does not have Super Cow Powers.

aptitude might not be installed by default. To install it, do sudo apt-get install aptitude or click this: aptitude Install aptitude.

Extra

The following information doesn’t really directly answer “What is the difference between dpkg and aptitude/apt-get?” but it contributes to the big picture.

From Carlos Campderrós’ comment below:

gdebi is another tool that is kind of a mixture between apt-get and aptitude. When you use it to install a .deb package (gdebi packageName.deb), it will identify the missing dependencies, install them using apt-get, and then finally install and configure the package using dpkg. It even has a simple and neat GUI that gives you information about the .deb package, the files included in the package, and what dependencies need to be installed. To see this GUI, you would do gdebi-gtk packageName.deb. You can give gdebi a try by installing it with sudo apt-get install gdebi or click this: gdebi Install gdebi.

I don’t want to confuse anyone, but just to give you another part of the picture, there is another popular Linux package format called RPM, and its files have the .rpm extension. This package format is used on RPM-based Linux distributions (such as Red Hat, CentOS, and Fedora). They use the command rpm to install a package, and yum is the front-end for it, it’s the clever one. So their .rpm files are our .deb files, their rpm tool is our dpkg tool, and their yum is our apt-get.

From Paddy Landau’s comment below:

alien is a tool that converts between .rpm and .deb packages. So if you ever fall into the situation where you have an .rpm package, and you want to install in on your Ubuntu (or any other Debian-based distro), you can use the command alien rpm_packageName.rpm to convert it to .deb, and then install it using dpkg. You can do the reverse (convert .deb to .rpm) using alien -r packageName.deb.

Comments